Lake Phalen vs McCarron Lake
Two of the top-scoring lakes in Ramsey County, Minnesota, side by side.
Lake Phalen is the larger of the two at 198 acres against 73 for McCarron Lake. On our rankings, Lake Phalen comes out ahead for fishing, McCarron Lake comes out ahead for swimming, Lake Phalen comes out ahead for boating, McCarron Lake comes out ahead for paddling, and Lake Phalen comes out ahead for ice fishing.
| Measure | Lake Phalen | McCarron Lake |
|---|---|---|
| Lake Score | 68 / 100 | 68 / 100 |
| Nearest town | Saint Paul | Roseville |
| Surface area | 198 acres | 73 acres |
| Max depth | 91 ft | 57 ft |
| Shoreline | 3 mi | 1.5 mi |
| Water clarity | 10.4 ft | 14 ft |
| Public access | 1 public boat launch (concrete) | 1 public boat launch (asphalt) |
| Fish species | 11 | 13 |
| Game fish | Walleye, Northern Pike, Largemouth Bass, Black Crappie, Bluegill | Walleye, Northern Pike, Largemouth Bass, Smallmouth Bass, Black Crappie |
| Stocked | Yes | No |
| Special regulations | Yes | No |
| Swim beach | Yes | Yes |
| Camping | No | No |
| Invasive species | Eurasian watermilfoil, zebra mussel | Eurasian watermilfoil, zebra mussel |
Which lake is better for…
- FishingLake Phalen
- SwimmingMcCarron Lake
- BoatingLake Phalen
- PaddlingMcCarron Lake
- Ice FishingLake Phalen
The lakes
More comparisons
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is bigger, Lake Phalen or McCarron Lake?
Lake Phalen is bigger at 198 acres; McCarron Lake covers 73 acres.
Which is deeper, Lake Phalen or McCarron Lake?
Lake Phalen is deeper, with a maximum depth of 91 feet against 57 feet.
Is Lake Phalen or McCarron Lake better for fishing?
Lake Phalen ranks higher for fishing in this directory, based on game species, lake size, access and stocking. Lake Phalen lists 11 species and McCarron Lake lists 13.